you can opt out of Medicare; you can’t opt out of its cuts.
another round of the same story
Roughly 1% of physicians have formally stopped accepting Medicare patients. While the reasons may vary, low reimbursement and frequent payment cuts are often among the reasons cited. This share appears small, perhaps making it tempting to ignore the concern of Medicare cuts as most physicians stay. However, those who opt out are still affected.
This is because Medicare and private payers aren’t separate camps. Private payers pay more than the government, which feels intuitive regardless of geography, specialty, or practice type. That doesn’t mean they work in silos. Medicare payment sets the standard for private payers to follow, and often they don’t even need an excuse.
Plenty of commercial physician contracts aren’t negotiated by individual codes uncontextualized. Frequently, they’re written as a percentage of the Medicare fee schedule, whether that be 130%, 150%, whatever both sides landed on. When the Medicare conversion factor drops 2.31% for most clinicians, as it does in the 2027 final rule, those contracts drop with it. This drop is automatic, not requiring extra negotiation of buy in from physicians. Although contracts with fixed dollar schedules don’t reprice automatically, at time of renewal, Medicare’s number is the first thing the payer’s negotiator points to.
Framing this only as a Medicare patient access problem misses half of it. Medicare steadily acts as the reference point every other negotiation starts from. This is irrespective of physicians who have opted out of Medicare as they can’t opt out of the economics it creates.
In most years, physician advocacy groups’ top priority is avoiding Medicare cuts, and in most years CMS finalizes another reduction. With some of the brightest brains in medicine advocating across partisan lines, it seems surprising the only “win” it seems is a one-year 2.5% bump… and it expired on schedule.
Physicians won some of the most closely watched races this November, in both parties, and the new Congress will have at least 18 of them. The question is whether that influence can move past another temporary reprieve toward a system where physicians don’t fight the same cuts every December.
I hope it does!